Monday, May 10, 2010

Kagan = Obama

I find it hard to disagree with Glenn Greenwald's analysis regarding the choice of Elena Kagan to replace Justice Stevens. Regardless of whether one's position on the appropriateness of the choice, as Greenwald argues, Kagan and President Obama have a lot in common that satisfies professional Democratic politicians. Here is a core passage from Greenwald's article:
The New York Times this morning reports that "Mr. Obama effectively framed the choice so that he could seemingly take the middle road by picking Ms. Kagan, who correctly or not was viewed as ideologically between Judge Wood on the left and Judge Garland in the center." That's consummate Barack Obama. The Right appoints people like John Roberts and Sam Alito, with long and clear records of what they believe because they're eager to publicly defend their judicial philosophy and have the Court reflect their values. Beltway Democrats do the opposite: the last thing they want is to defend what progressives have always claimed is their worldview, either because they fear the debate or because they don't really believe those things, so the path that enables them to avoid confrontation of ideas is always the most attractive, even if it risks moving the Court to the Right.
 Great points.

4 comments:

commoncents said...

Thank You for posting this! I really like your blog - keep up the great work!!
Common Cents
http://www.commoncts.blogspot.com

ps. Link Exchange/??

liberal dissent said...

I am not thrilled with the Kagan pick; and I am especially not impressed with the White House's description of her as "one of the nation's top legal minds," which is just ridiculous. I see nothing wrong with appointing a politician, elected or non-elected, to the Supreme Court, but be honest about it.

Darren Lenard Hutchinson said...

Honesty and politics? Grab hold of your senses, LD.

liberal dissent said...

I know, maybe I just want them to at least put more effort into coming up with credible dishonesty. There is no way that producing 5 journal articles, primarily on administrative law issues, makes one a "top legal mind."

Real Time Analytics